9 ‘American Idol’ Contestants Who Definitely Should Have Won9 ‘American Idol’ Contestants Who Definitely Should Have WonFrom Melinda Doolittle to Pia Toscano, these eliminated finalists deserved MUCH better.Matthew Scott DonnellyMatthew Scott Donnelly
‘American Idol’ Contestants Jena Irene + Caleb Johnson Attend Prom Together‘American Idol’ Contestants Jena Irene + Caleb Johnson Attend Prom TogetherSeason 13 contestants Jena Irene and Caleb Johnson proved their friendship extends beyond the competition when he escorted her to the North Farmington High School prom!Maggie MalachMaggie Malach