On tonight’s (July 12) penultimate episode of Season 1 of ‘Duets,’ judges’ favorite John Glosson was actually in the bottom two, along with Bridget Carrington. It was Carrington, the amateur partner of superstar John Legend, who was voted off and sent home by the American public. We’re bummed to see her go since she had so much charisma.

Carrington, who is a tax collector by day, coming after people who don’t pay Uncle Sam, was gracious in defeat. She looked like a diva in her black leather ensemble, too. Her mentor Legend hit the stage to send her her off, but not before gushing about how proud he was to have had the chance to work with her during the show’s maiden voyage season.

With Carrington sent home, that means that superstar Jennifer Nettles has two finalists competing in the form of Glosson and J. Rome. They will compete against Kelly Clarkson‘s charge, Jason Farol, to be crowned the first season winner of ‘Duets.’ That’s what we call making history.

Tune in next week to find out who wins ‘Duets.’ Any predictions?

Watch Kelly Clarkson + John Legend Perform ‘You Don’t Know Me’ on ‘Duets’